Injured? Contact Sinas Dramis for a free consultation.

Welcome to the Michigan Auto No-Fault Law Digital Library

The Michigan No-Fault Act was adopted in 1973, and since then, there have been over 4000 Michigan appellate court opinions regarding the law. Sinas Dramis Law Firm has written case summaries regarding virtually all these opinions and continues to do so at the present time. The Michigan Auto No-Fault Law Digital Library is a compilation of all the case summaries from Sinas Dramis Law Firm. The case summaries are freely provided to further our goal of educating the public about the Michigan Auto No-Fault Law.

The Digital Library is fully searchable. Therefore, searching by case name or relevant terms is a good way to find the case summary and opinion. There is also an indexing system that allows you to find a case through a statutory index, topical index, alphabetical index, or chronological index.


To make it easy for the public to understand the latest developments in the law, the recent case summaries are listed below.

Recent Cases

Settler v Auto-Owners Insurance Company, et al (COA – UNP 8/10/2023; RB #4628)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s summary disposition order dismissing Plaintiff Hiram Settler’s action for no-fault PIP benefits against Defendant Auto-Owners Insurance Company (“Auto-Owners”). The Court of Appeals held, first, that under Meemic Ins Co v Fortson, 506 Mich 287 (2020) and Haydaw v Farm Bureau Ins Co, 332 Mich App 719 (2020), Auto-Owners could still deny specific, fraudulent claims for benefits made by Settler, even if it could not altogether void the policy under which Settler was claiming benefits on the basis …

Scott v Esurance Prop and Cas Ins Co (COA – UNP 8/3/2023; RB #4625)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s denial of Defendant Esurance Property and Casualty Insurance Company’s (“Esurance”) motion for summary disposition, in which Esurance sought dismissal of Plaintiff Valere Scott’s action for unpaid no-fault PIP benefits. The Court of Appeals found no issue of material fact as to whether Scott was logged onto a ridesharing application at the time of the subject motor vehicle accident and thus barred from PIP benefits due to a coverage exclusion authorized under MCLs 500.3113(e) and 500.3017. Vale …

Wright v City of Detroit, et al (COA – UNP 8/10/2023; RB #4626)

In this 2-1, unpublished, per curiam decision (Jansen dissenting), the Court of Appeals vacated the trial court’s summary disposition order dismissing Plaintiff Nakisha Wright’s automobile negligence action against Defendants Roderick Hartley and the City of Detroit (“the City”). The Court of Appeals held, first, that there was a question of fact as to whether Hartley, a bus driver for the City of Detroit, acted with gross negligence when he “violently and aggressively” accelerated while Wright was still walking to her seat after boarding the bus. The Court of Appeals held, second, that Wright …

Amos, et al v Progressive Marathon Ins Co (COA – UNP 7/13/2023; RB #4606)

In this 2-1, unpublished, per curiam decision (Letica, dissenting), the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s denial of Defendant Progressive Marathon Insurance Company’s (“Progressive”) motion for summary disposition, in which it sought it sought dismissal of Plaintiff Omar Akeem Amos’s action for no-fault PIP benefits. The Court of Appeals held that a question of fact existed as to whether Amos had “unlawfully taken” a vehicle for purposes of MCL 500.3113(a).

Dairyland Ins Co v Mews, et al (COA – PUB 7/20/2023; RB #4610)

In this unanimous, published decision authored by Judge Patel and dealing with multiple consolidated appeals, the Court of Appeals issued a lengthy decision in which it held that for purposes of summary disposition under MCR 2.116(C)(6), the lawsuit filed in the Wayne County Circuit Court filed by medical providers, ICM and Diversified Home Health Care (“Diversified”), was the proper case through which to litigate the common issues regarding Dairyland Insurance Company (“Dairyland”) responsibiities to pay no-fault benefits owed to an injured person, Cameron Mews, because the Wayne County case …

Ali v Meemic Ins Co (COA – UNP 7/20/2023; RB #4612)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals vacated the trial court’s denial of Defendant Meemic Insurance Company’s (“Meemic”) post-judgment motion for case evaluation sanctions against Plaintiff Faiz Ali and affirmed the trial court’s denial of Ali’s request for attorney fees under MCL 500.3148(1). The Court of Appeals held that MCR 2.403(O)—which subsection was removed entirely from the Court Rules when they were amended in January 1, 2022—applied to Ali’s action, and that case evaluation sanctions should have been awarded in Meemic’s favor. The Court also held …

Wasenko v The Auto Club Group, et al (COA – PUB 7/20/2023; RB #4613)

In this 2-1, published decision authored by Judge Yates (Judge Shaprio, dissenting), the Court of Appeals vacated the trial court’s order regarding a charging lien asserted by Nabih Ayad over future attendant care benefits received by his client, Steven Wasenko. The Court of Appeals held that the trial court erred in resolving a dispute over the language in the contingent fee agreement entered into by Wasenko and Ayad by applying MCL 500.3148(4).

Thomas, et al v Old Republic Ins Group, et al (COA – UNP 7/20/2023; RB #4614)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s denial of Defendant Transguard Insurance Company of America’s (“Transguard”) motion for summary disposition, in which Transguard sought dismissal of Plaintiff Justin Thomas’s action for unpaid no-fault PIP benefits. The Court of Appeals found a question of fact as to whether an Illinois insurance policy provided Michigan no-fault coverage to a driver—Thomas—injured while driving a truck for his employer in Wisconsin.

Davis v Hurd, et al (COA – UNP 7/6/2023; RB #4605)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s summary disposition order dismissing Plaintiff Robert Davis’s automobile negligence action against Defendant Jonathan Hurd. The Court of Appeals held that a question of fact existed as to whether Davis satisfied the third prong of the test for “serious impairment of body function” set forth in MCL 500.3135 and McCormick v Carrier, 487 Mich 180 (2010).

Adams, et al v Liberty Mutual Group, Inc, et al (COA – UNP 7/27/2023; RB #4617)

In this 2-1, unpublished, per curiam opinion (Boonstra, dissenting), the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s summary disposition order dismissing Plaintiff William Adams’s action for uninsured motorist (“UM”) coverage against Defendant Liberty Mutual Group, Inc. (“Liberty Mutual”). The Court of Appeals held that Adams presented sufficient evidence to satisfy a provision in the UM endorsement to his policy with Liberty Mutual which required that, in order to claim UM coverage for a hit-and-run collision, the insured present ‘competent evidence [that the collision occurred] other than th …

Enhance Ctr for Interventional Spine and Sports v Allstate Ins Co, et al (COA – UNP 7/27/2023; RB #4618)

Enhance Ctr for Interventional Spine and Sports v Allstate Ins Co, et al (COA – UNP 7/27/2023; RB #4618)Michigan Court of Appeals; Docket #361517; UnpublishedJudges Cameron, Borrello, and O’Brien; Per CuriamOfficial Michigan Reporter Citation: Not Applicable; Link to Opinion STATUTORY INDEX:Exception for Motorcycle Injuries [§3114(5)] TOPICAL INDEX:Not Applicable SUMMARY: In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals vacated the trial court’s order dismissing Defendant Progressive Michigan Insurance Company (“Progressive”) from Plaintiff Enhance Center for Interventi …

Chisholm v State Police, et al (COA – PUB 8/3/2023; RB #4623)

In this unanimous, published, per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s denial of Defendant State Police and State of Michigan’s (“the State”) motion for summary disposition, in which they sought dismissal of Plaintiff Joseph Chisholm’s automobile negligence action and action for no-fault PIP benefits. The Court of Appeals held, first, that Chisholm satisfied the requirements of MCL 600.6431 by filing a notice of intent to file a claim within six months of the date of the subject motor vehicle crash. The Court of Appeals held, second, that Chisholm’s notice—which was …

Wilson v Duron, et al (COA – UNP 8/31/2023; RB #4622)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s denial of Defendant Livonia Public School’s (“Livonia Public Schools”) motion for summary disposition, in which it sought dismissal of Plaintiff Rachel Wilson’s automobile negligence action. The Court of Appeals held, first, that the trial court did not abuse its discretion by letting Wilson amend her complaint to explicitly cite MCL 691.1405, the statute which sets forth the motor vehicle exception to governmental immunity. The Court of Appeals held, second, that a question of fact existed as t …

Al-Rahimi, et al v Allstate Ins Co, et al (COA – UNP 8/17/2023; RB #4621)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s summary disposition order dismissing Plaintiff Jamal Al-Rahimi’s automobile negligence action against Defendant Sophia Ryana Oakes. The Court of Appeals held that a question of fact existed as to whether Al-Rahimi’s impairments affected his general ability to lead his normal life—the third prong in the test for “serious impairment of body function,” set forth in MCL 500.3135 and McCormick v Carrier, 487 Mich 180 (2010).

Batton v Auto Owners Ins, et al (COA – UNP 8/3/2023; RB #4620)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s summary disposition order dismissing Plaintiff Zane Lee Batton’s automobile negligence action against Defendant Scott David Romesburg. The Court of Appeals held that a question of fact existed as to whether Romesburg was more than 50% at-fault for crashing his motor vehicle into Batton, a bicyclist.

Frankenmuth Mut Ins Co v Mich Auto Ins Placement Facility (COA – UNP 8/10/2023; RB #4624)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s summary disposition order in favor of Plaintiff Frankenmuth Mutual Insurance Company (“Frankenmuth”), in Frankenmuth’s priority dispute with Defendant Michigan Automobile Insurance Placement Facility (MAIPF). The Court of Appeals held that Wendy Edenburn was not domiciled with her father, Frankenmuth’s insured, on the date of her motor vehicle crash.

Lang v Liberty Mut Ins Co (COA – UNP 7/20/2023; RB #4615)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s denial of Defendant Liberty Mutual Insurance Company’s (“Liberty Mutual”) motion for summary disposition—in which it sought dismissal of Plaintiff Xavier Lang’s action for unpaid no-fault PIP benefits—and remanded for entry of an order granting summary disposition in Liberty Mutual’s favor. The Court of Appeals held that Lang failed to present sufficient evidence to create a question of fact as to whether Liberty Mutual was responsible for his claimed medical expenses.

McCauley, et al v Progressive Marathon Ins Co (COA – UNP 7/20/2023; RB #4611)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s summary disposition order dismissing Plaintiff Angela McCauley’s action for unpaid no-fault PIP benefits against Defendant Progressive Marathon Insurance Company (“Progressive”). The Court of Appeals found a question of fact as to whether McCauley’s brother committed fraud when he procured an insurance policy on which McCauley was listed as a named insured, and also as to whether McCauley was an innocent third party with respect to her brother’s alleged fraud.

Jordan v Allstate Ins Co (COA – UNP 7/27/2023; RB #4616)

In this unanimous, unpublished, per curiam decision, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s denial of Defendant Allstate Insurance Company’s (“Allstate”) motion for summary disposition, in which Allstate sought dismissal of Plaintiff Keisha Jordan’s action for unpaid no-fault PIP benefits. The Court of Appeals found a question of fact as to whether Jordan was domiciled with her grandparents, Allstate’s insureds, at the time of the subject motor vehicle accident.

Wilmore-Moody v Zakir, et al (UNP – COA 5/6/2021; RB # 4260)

In this unanimous (6-0) decision authored by Justice Cavanagh, the Supreme Court held that if an insurer rescinds a policy ab initio after a loss, that does not mean the policyholder was uninsured on the date of loss for purposes of MCL 500.3135(2)(c).