Ashcraft v McLaughlin; (COA-UNP, 4/25/2006, RB #2732)
Print this case summary (opens in a new tab)
Michigan Court of Appeals; Docket #266116; Unpublished
Judges Murphy, O’Connell, and Murray; 2-1 (Judge O’Connell concurring in result only); per curiam
Official Michigan Reporter Citation: Not applicable, Link to Opinion ![]()
STATUTORY INDEXING:
Serious Impairment of Body Function Definition (Kreiner Era – 1996-2010) [3135(7)]
Determining Permanent Serious Disfigurement As a Matter of Law [3135(1)(2)]
TOPICAL INDEXING:
Not applicable
CASE SUMMARY:
In this 2-1 unpublished per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals affirmed summary disposition for defendant, finding that a 2¾ inch scar on plaintiff’s hip was not a permanent serious disfigurement under MCL 500.3135(1) of the No-Fault Act. In so finding, the court noted that nearly all facial scars that are immediately noticeable may constitute a serious disfigurement, however, common sense dictates that a scar on a person’s hip will have less of an emotional impact. In this regard, the court stated:
“The impact of a scar largely lies in the emotional effects it has on an individual. . . . The seriousness of a scar is nonetheless decided by a resort to common knowledge and experience, using an objective, rather than a subjective, standard. . . . Whether a scar is a serious disfigurement depends on its physical characteristics. . . . This Court has stated that ‘[a]lmost any facial scar which is immediately noticeable might result in serious emotional effects for the individual who must bear the scar.’ . . . The evidence in this case reveals that plaintiff has a scar that is approximately 2-3/4 inches long in her hip area. Although the scar is noticeable, common sense dictates that such a scar will have less of an emotional effect on an individual than a 2-3/4-inch facial scar. Considering all of the scar’s physical characteristics, including its size, location, pigmentation, and irregular shape, we agree with the trial court that it constitutes a disfigurement, but does not have the requisite seriousness to satisfy MCL 500.3135(1). Therefore, we affirm the trial court’s determination that plaintiff failed to show that her permanent disfigurement was serious”
Statute sections: Determining Permanent Serious Disfigurement As a Matter of Law [§3135(1)(2)], Serious Impairment of Body Function Definition (Kreiner Era: 1996-2010) [§3135(7)]
Decision year: 2006
