§500.3109:     GOVERNMENTAL BENEFITS SUBTRACTION; PIP DEDUCTIBLES

Standards for Deductibility of State and Federal Governmental Benefits [§3109(1)]

• Spectrum Health Hospitals, et al v Citizens Ins Co of America, et al (COA – UNP 5/18/2023; RB #4585)
• Batts v Titan Ins Co (COA - PUB; 12/12/2017; RB # 3694)
• Wood v Auto-Owners Insurance Company; (MSC, 9/9/2003, RB #2388)
• Heller v Citizens Insurance Company of America; (COA-UNP, 9/4/2001, RB #2240)
• Auto-Owners Insurance Company v Transamerica Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 11/30/1999; RB #2114)
• Farmers Insurance Exchange and Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association v South Lyon Community Schools; (COA-PUB, 8/17/1999; RB #2089)
• Liberty Mutual Fire Ins Co v Ross (COA - UNP; 7/25/2017; RB # 3654)
• Booth v Auto Owners Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 7/25/1997; RB #1948)
• Michigan Educational Employees Mutual Ins Co v Morris and Auto-Owners Ins Co v Perry; (MSC, 6/29/1999; RB #2082)
• Gunsell v Ryan; (COA-PUB, 6/15/1999; RB #2064)
• Specht v Citizens Insurance Co of America; (COA-PUB, 2/26/1999; RB #2044)
• Walker v Farmers Insurance Exchange; (COA-PUB, 10/21/1997; RB #1974)
• Auto Owners Insurance Company v Eversman; (COA-UNP, 7/30/1996; RB #1882)
• Minster v State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 5/31/1996; RB #1860)
• McCain v Auto-Owners Insurance Company (On Rehearing); (COA-PUB, 5/2/1997; RB #1959)
• McCain v Auto Owners Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 12/20/1996; RB #1903)
• Michigan Educational Employees Mutual Insurance Company v Morris; (COA-UNP, 11/22/1996; RB #1895)
• Root v Insurance Company of North America; (COA-PUB, 10/24/1995; RB #1826)
• DeMeglio v Auto Club Insurance Association; (MSC-PUB, 6/20/1995; RB #1779)
• Schell v Farmers Insurance Exchange; (COA-UNP, 3/8/1995; RB #1770)
• Popma v Auto Club Insurance Association; (MSC-PUB, 8/26/1994; RB #1717)
• Hicks v Citizens Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 3/8/1994; RB #1703)
• Westchester Fire Insurance Co v Safeco Insurance Co; (COA-PUB, 2/22/1994; RB #1802)
• Langs v Allstate Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 12/15/1993; RB #1688)
• Wesolek v City of Saginaw and Michigan Municipal Risk Management Authority; (COA-PUB, 12/6/1993; RB #1678)
• Demeglio v Auto Club Insurance Association; (COA-PUB, 11/2/1993; RB #1671)
• Profit v Citizens Insurance Company of America; (MSC-PUB, 9/29/1993; RB #1632)
• Owens and Herrick Memorial Hospital y Auto Club Insurance Association; (MSC-PUB, 9/29/1993; RB #1631)
• Tyckoski v American Fellowship Mutual Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 8/10/1993; RB #1639)
• Vanover and Chilton Insurance Company v Commercial Carriers Inc; (USD-UNP, 8/5/1993; RB #1661)
• Popma v Auto Club Insurance Association; (COA-PUB, 5/18/1993; RB #1615)
• Aetna Casualty & Surety Company v American Community Mutual Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 11/19/1992; RB #1582)
• Botsford General Hospital v Noel and Citizens Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 7/20/1992; RB #1553)
• Owens and Herrick Memorial Hospital v Auto Club Insurance Association; (COA-UNP, 2/5/1992; RB #1532)
• Allstate Insurance Company v Health Alliance Plan (on remand); (COA-UNP, 1/15/1992; RB #1529)
• Guenther v Detroit Automobile Inter-Insurance Exchange; (COA-UNP, 11/20/1991; RB #1517)
• John Hancock Property and Casualty Insurance Companies v Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Michigan and Employers Mutual Insurance Companies v American Community Mutual Insurance Company; (MSC-PUB, 6/24/1991; RB #1492)
• Profit v Citizens Insurance Company of America; (COA-PUB, 1/22/1991; RB #1443)
• Allstate Insurance Company v Health Alliance Plan; (COA-UNP, 7/31/1990; RB #1396)
• Shields v Farmers Insurance Group; (COA-UNP, 6/27/1990; RB #1388)
• Sibley v Detroit Automobile Inter-Insurance Exchange II; (COA-UNP, 4/10/1990; RB #1361)
• Campbell v Auto Owners Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 2/7/1990; RB #1338)
• Spencer v Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company; (COA-PUB, 8/9/1989; RB #1286)
• Morgan v Citizens Insurance Company of America; (MSC-PUB, 7/18/1989; RB # 1269)
• Conrad v Auto Club Insurance Association; (COA-PUB, 6/20/1989; RB #1280)
• Clute v General Accident Assurance Co of Canada (Second Appeal); (COA-UNP, 6/8/1989; RB #1262)
• Conway v Continental Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 5/18/1989; RB #1327)
• Allstate Insurance Company v Sentry Insurance Company of Michigan; (COA-UNP, 2/22/1989; RB # 1222)
• Tatum v Government Employees Insurance Company; (MSC-PUB, 11/16/1988; RB #1172)
• Pollard v Auto-Owners Insurance Company; (CCC- ___ ; 10/3/1988; RB# 1195)
• Moore v Auto-Club Insurance Association; (COA-PUB, 9/12/1988; RB #1179)   
• Sibley v DAIIE; (MSC-PUB, 8/23/1988; RB #1146)
• Morse v Auto-Owners Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 5/31/1988; RB  #1133)
• Taylor v Auto Club Insurance Association; (OCC-UNP, 5/3/1988; RB # 1144)
• Owens v Auto Club Insurance Association; (WCC-UNP, 5/2/1988; RB # 1143)
• Pellerito v State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 3/29/1988; RB # 1125)
• Pokosnik v United Canada Insurance Co; (COA-PUB, 2/17/1988; RB # 1111)
• McKim II v Home Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 10/20/1987; RB #1086)
• Morgan v Evans; (COA-PUB, 9/10/1987; RB # 1079)
• Parham v Preferred Risk Mutual Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 7/31/1987; RB #1098)
• Joiner v Michigan Mutual Ins Co; (COA-PUB, 7/7/1987; RB #1068)
• Crowley v DAIIE and Western Casualty; (MSC-PUB, 6/22/1987; RB #1022)
• Russell v Welcor, Inc; (COA-PUB, 1/21/1987; RB #1025)
• Brass v Citizens Insurance Company of America; (COA-UNP, 1/12/1987; RB #1003)
• Sibley v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 12/2/1986; RB #973)
• Gregory v Transamerica Insurance Company; (MSC-PUB, 8/7/1986; RB #934)
• Cook v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 5/9/1986; RB #940)
• Fulkerson v Providence Washington Insurance Company, et al; (COA-UNP, 4/11/1986; RB #939)
• Grau v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 12/17/1985; RB #890)
• Sheeks v Farmers Insurance; (COA-PUB, 10/8/1985; RB #875)
• Crowley v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 7/16/1985; RB  #857)
• Tennant v State Farm; (COA-PUB, 6/4/1985; RB #840)
• Cannell v Riverside Insurance Co; (COA-PUB, 5/9/1985; RB #898)
• Sharp v Preferred Risk Mutual Ins Co; (COA-PUB, 5/7/1985; RB #834)
• Perkins v Riverside Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 3/18/1985; RB  #828)
• Divito v Transamerica Corporation; (COA-PUB, 2/20/1985; RB #822)
• Kuty v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 1/23/1985; RB #810)
• Deppmeier v Associated Truck Lines, Inc; (COA-UNP, 12/12/1984; RB  #806)
• Gregory v Transamerica Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 12/3/1984; RB #792)
• Cole v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 9/18/1984; RB #765)
• Joiner v Michigan Mutual; (COA-PUB, 9/17/1984; RB # 767)
• Grau v DAIIE, et at.; (KCC-UNP, 9/5/1984; RB  #772)
• Crowley v DAIIE; (WCC-UNP, 6/21/1984; RB #769)
• Krygel v City of Detroit; (COA-PUB, 6/5/1984; RB #684)
• James v Allstate; (COA-PUB, 3/23/1984; RB #726)
• Thompson v DAIIE; (MSC-PUB, 3/12/1984; RB #703)
• Jarosz v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 3/12/1984; RB #702)
• Perez v State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company; (MSC-PUB, 3/12/1984; RB #701)
• Tebo v Havlik/Burns v Carver; (MSC-PUB, 2/6/1984; RB #700)
• United States of America v Jackson and AAA Insurance Company; (USD-UNP, 10/5/1983; RB #1236)
• Insurance Bureau Bulletin 83-04; (___-___, 6/6/1983; RB #675)
• Smith v DAIIE; (COA-PUB; 4/5/1983; RB #638)
• Perkins v Riverside Insurance Company; (ICC-___, 4/4/1983; RB #649)
• Attorney General Opinion 6111; (___,___, 12/13/82; RB #627)
• Bunce v DAIIE; (WCC-UNP, 11/12/1982; RB #591)
• Moshier v Financial Indemnity Company II; (COA-PUB, 10/18/1982; RB #578)
• Harris v DAIIE; (JDC-UNP, 7/20/1982; RB #559)
• Doublin v Kroger Company; (WCC-UNP, 7/20/1982; RB #556)
• Hammermeister v Riverside Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 5/21/1982; RB #525)
• Davis and Attorney General v Auto-Owners Insurance Company, et al; (COA-PUB, 5/20/1982; RB #524)
• Featherly v AAA Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 4/19/1982; RB #519)
• Iverson v Michigan-Mutual; (MCC-UNP, 3/30/1982; RB #531)
• Thacker v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 3/18/1982; RB #511)
• Luth v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 2/17/1982; RB #496)
• Schultz v Farmers Insurance Exchange; (COA-UNP, 1/11/1982; RB # 590)
• Jarosz v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 9/8/1981; RB #441)
• Burns v Farmers Ins Group; (USD-UNP, 9/1/1981; RB #446)
• Thompson v DAIIE; (COA-PUB, 6/16/1981; RB #426)
• Baker v Transit Casualty Co; (USD-UNP, 6/8/1981; RB #445)
• LaMoria v DAIIE; (LCC-UNP, 7/31/1980 & 5/18/1981; RB #447)
• Perez v State Farm; (COA-PUB, 4/8/1981; RB #395)
• Moshier v Financial Indemnity Company; (KCC-UNP, 4/3/1981; RB #412)
• Featherly v AAA Insurance Company; (ICC-UNP, 4/1/1981; RB #411)
• LeBlanc v State Farm; (MSC-PUB, 2/3/1981; RB #377)
• Hammermeister v Riverside Insurance Company; (OCC-UNP, 12/31/1980; RB #406)
• Dedrick v DAIIE; (JDC-UNP, 7/9/1981; RB # 449)
• LaMoria v DAIIE; (LCC-UNP, 7/31/1980 & 5/18/1981; RB #447)    
• Nuculaj v State Farm; (WCC-UNP, 10/27/1980; RB #364) 
• Bagley v State Farm; (COA-PUB, 8/22/1980; RB # 356)  
• Swanson v Citizens Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 7/23/1980; RB #340)  
• Neumann v Transit Casualty Company; (COA-PUB, 4/1/1980; RB # 294)
• Mathis v Interstate Motor Freight System; Hawkins v Auto-Owners; Ottenwess v Hawkeye; (MSC-PUB, 3/20/1980; RB #292)  
• Wolford v Travelers Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 10/1/1979; RB #234)
• Ostrowski v The United States Department of Labor et al; (USD-PUB, 9/18/1979; RB #325)
• Moore v Travelers Insurance Company; (USD-PUB, 9/3/1979; RB #465)  
• Becker v Cavalier Insurance Company; (ICC-UNP, 8/14/1979; RB #226)
  
• Bagley v State Farm; (MCC-UNP, 7/10/1979; RB #222)
• Lindsey v Hartford; (COA-PUB, 6/6/1979; RB #196)
• Miller v State Farm; (COA-PUB, 1/17/1979; RB #158)
• Workman v DAIIE; (MSC-PUB; 1/4/1979; RB #143)
• O'Donnell v State Farm; (MSC-PUB; 1/4/1979; RB #142)  
• LeBlanc v State Farm; (COA-PUB, 12/6/1978; RB #132) 
• Bessette v Michigan Mutual; (ICC-UNP, 11/1/1978, RB #133)
• Lose v Yanks, Inc.; (ICC-UNP, 9/29/1978; RB #117)  
• Neumann v Transit Casualty Company; (OCC-UNP, 9/15/1978; RB #135)
• Goldsworthy v Royal Globe Insurance Company; (COA-UNP, 8/10/1978; RB #159)     
• Greene v State Farm; (COA-PUB, 5/22/1978; RB #89)
• Smart v Citizens Mutual; (COA-PUB, 5/8/1978; RB #75)
  
• O'Donnell v State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company; (COA-PUB, 8/4/1976; RB #20)  
• Mathis v Home Insurance Company; (GCC-UNP, 5/27/1976; RB #23)
• Meyer v Michigan Mutual Liability Company; (ICC-UNP, 3/10/1976; RB #17)
• Shavers v Attorney General, et al; (COA-PUB, 11/5/1975; RB #12)