Print this page · Back to the summary

American Fidelity Fire Insurance Company v Martin; (WCC-UNP, 1/30/1980; RB #272)

January 30, 1980 · WCC UNP · RB #272

Wayne County Circuit Court; Docket No. 79-920175-CK; Unpublished  
Judge William J. Giovan; Written Opinion  
Official Michigan Reporter Citation: Not Applicable; Link to Opinion alt   


STATUTORY INDEXING:  
Scope of Mandated Coverages [§3131(1)]

TOPICAL INDEXING:
Motor Vehicle Code (Financial Responsibility Act) (MCL 257.501, et seq.)   


CASE SUMMARY:  
In a written Opinion, Judge Giovan held that a liability insurer could not avoid liability on a tort judgment on the basis that the insured failed to cooperate in the defense. Judge Giovan noted that §3131 of the no-fault act specifies what kind of residual liability insurance coverage is required. That section refers to compliance with the Financial Responsibility Act The applicable provision of that Act [MCLA 257.520(f)(1)] negates the noncooperation of the insured as a defense by the insurer against the judgment creditor. Since §3131 of the No-Fault Act incorporates those provisions for the residual liability coverage mandated by the Act, the noncooperation of an insured person does not relieve the insurer of liability for a tort judgment

Judge Giovan noted that the statutes construed do not expressly prohibit an insurer from abandoning the defense of a noncooperating insured. However, liability on the judgment could not be avoided.

Source: Auto No Fault Law Digital Library — https://autonofaultlaw.com/digital-library/case-summaries/3948-american-fidelity-fire-insurance-company-v-martin-wcc-unp-1301980-rb-272/