Print this page · Back to the summary

Rhoads v Auto Club Insurance Association; (COA-UNP, 4/12/1995; RB #1782)

April 12, 1995 · COA UNP · RB #1782

Michigan Court of Appeals; Docket No. 160772; Unpublished  
Judges White, Smolenski, and Danhof; Unanimous; Per Curiam  
Official Michigan Reporter Citation:  Not Applicable; Link to Opinion   


STATUTORY INDEXING:  
Not Applicable

TOPICAL INDEXING:  
Not Applicable   


CASE SUMMARY:  
In this unanimous per curiam unpublished Opinion, the Court of Appeals upheld the administrative finding by the Insurance Commissioner that petitioner was substantially at fault in two separate accidents and could therefore be assessed a surcharge to his insurance policy, pursuant to MCLA 500.2111.   

The Court of Appeals noted than an administrative agency’s final decision is to be upheld if it is authorized by law and supported by competent, material, and substantial evidence on the whole record.  

Under MCLA 500.2111, an insurance company may approve a surcharge if the insurer can show that the insured was substantially at fault in an accident. Under MCLA 500.2104(4), substantially at fault means a person’s action or inaction was more than 50% of the cause of the accident.  

In reviewing the two accidents, the court found that the Insurance Commissioner’s decision was supported by competent, material, and substantial evidence that petitioner was substantially at fault in both accidents, and therefore, a surcharge was appropriate.  

Source: Auto No Fault Law Digital Library — https://autonofaultlaw.com/digital-library/case-summaries/2376-rhoads-v-auto-club-insurance-association-coa-unp-4121995-rb-1782/