Print this page · Back to the summary

Sarate v Ayers; ( CCC – UNP, 7/16/1998; RB #2077)

July 16, 1998 · CCC UNP · RB #2077

Oakland County Circuit Court; Case No. 96-534814-NI; Unpublished  
Honorable Robert C. Anderson (Honorable J. P. Jourdan)   
Official Michigan Reporter Citation:  Not Applicable; Link to Opinion alt  


STATUTORY INDEXING:   
Applicability of Comparative Fault to Noneconomic Loss Claims [§3135(2)]

TOPICAL INDEXING:   
Revised Judicature Act – Impairment Due to Alcohol and Drugs (MCL 600.2955(a))   


CASE SUMMARY:   
In this ruling from the bench, Judge Jourdan vacated an arbitration based upon plaintiff’s argument that the “more than 50% at fault” has for non-economic damages contained in amended section 3135(2)(b) applied to the instant case and not the “50% or more” bar contained in MCLA 600.2955a which would preclude recovery to a plaintiff impaired by his use of alcohol or drugs and found to be “50% or more” the cause of the accident.   

Plaintiff contended that the provisions of section 3135(3), which abolish tort liability except as to certain claims including non-economic loss as provided in subsection (2) “not withstanding any other provision of law” could only be interpreted to mean that the no-fault law clearly controls and that the separate statutory provision which would bar recovery for a person whose impairment was “50% or more” the cause of the accident did not apply.

Source: Auto No Fault Law Digital Library — https://autonofaultlaw.com/digital-library/case-summaries/2100-sarate-v-ayers-ccc-unp-7161998-rb-2077/