Print this page · Back to the summary

Olney v Fogg (COA-UNP, 04/26/12; RB #3257)

April 26, 2012 · COA UNP · RB #3257

Michigan Court of Appeals; Docket #301799; Unpublished
Judges Hoekstra, Sawyer, and Saad; Unanimous; Per Curiam
Official Michigan Reporter Citation:  Not applicable; Link to Opinioncourthouse graphic


STATUTORY INDEXING:       

Determining Serious Impairment of Body Function As a Matter of Law (McCormick Era: 2010 – present) [§3135(2)]    
Causation Issues [§3135

TOPICAL INDEXING:      
Not Applicable


In this unanimous per curiam unpublished Opinion, the Michigan Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s Order that granted plaintiff’s motion for a new trial in a third-party auto liability case.  Furthermore, the Court of Appeals rejected the plaintiff’s argument that the trial court erred in denying the plaintiff’s motion for summary disposition which argued the plaintiff had sustained a serious impairment of body function as a matter of law, pursuant to MCL 500.3135(7).

The plaintiff in this case claimed he sustained certain back injuries in an automobile accident that occurred on September 6, 2006.  Prior to the motor vehicle accident, it was undisputed that the plaintiff had pre-existing back and neck conditions, including a bulging disc in his cervical spine.  Following the subject motor vehicle accident, the plaintiff claimed his back conditions worsened and he required additional medical treatment.

There was a jury trial in the case.  The instructions the trial court judge read to the jury included M Civ JI 50.10, commonly known as “The Eggshell Skull Plaintiff” instruction.  In rendering its verdict, the jury answered “No” to the question of whether the plaintiff was “injured.”  Following the trial, the trial court judge talked with the jurors and counsel from both sides.  Apparently, during this conversation, the jurors made statements that indicated they did not apply the principles of M Civ JI 50.10.  Plaintiff’s counsel then used that conversation as the basis for his motion for a new trial.  The trial court granted the plaintiff’s motion.

The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s ruling that the plaintiff was entitled to a new trial.  The Court of Appeals reasoned that the jury had been properly instructed regarding M Civ JI 50.10 and that it is well-established under Michigan law that “jurors are presumed to follow their instructions.”  The Court of Appeals further stated that “we find it necessary to make the self-evident observation that it is absolutely improper to grant a new trial on the basis of impressions gleaned during an informal conversation with jurors after the trial is concluded.  Accordingly, we hold that the court abused its discretion by granting plaintiff’s motion for new trial and we, therefore, reverse.”

The Court of Appeals further rejected the plaintiff’s argument that prior to trial, the trial court erred in denying the plaintiff’s motion for summary disposition regarding whether the plaintiff had sustained a serious impairment of body function as a matter of law under MCL 500.3135(7).  The Court of Appeals did not provide a thorough explanation of its ruling on this issue.  The court simply stated there was extensive evidence on the record that the plaintiff had serious back problems before the accident and, therefore, “a genuine issue of material fact existed about whether he was ‘injured’ within the meaning of the no-fault act, MCL 500.3101, et seq.”

Source: Auto No Fault Law Digital Library — https://autonofaultlaw.com/digital-library/case-summaries/1854-olney-v-fogg-coa-unp-042612-rb-3257/